Homelessness


Whether you support or oppose the temporary housing locations, you’re right


It’s of no surprise that the issues around the temporary housing locations along with our significant homelessness issue are causing some serious problems throughout the community. Crime has been increasing throughout Nanaimo for quite some time. Without a doubt there is a concentrated increase in reported incidents in the neighbourhoods surrounding the temporary locations, however it would be false logic to attribute the establishment of the temporary locations as being the sole reason – correlation does not equal causation.

This isn’t a simple cause and effect type of situation, nor is it black and white – it’s a very complex subject. Prior to the establishment of these temporary locations, there were over 400 homeless individuals. That number has been essentially halved now, and whether they are there or dispersed throughout the city – the problems do not go away, nor are they responsible for them all.

You will find four specific action steps to take that I propose below. They are not all-encompassing, nor will they they fix everything – and they’re not intended to – they’re intended to spur action and shift things towards productive conversation. You can get right to the four specific action steps by clicking here if you wish, but there’s some other things before that to consider as well – so I hope you will just continue on reading.

I first want to acknowledge just a few points that have been raised by those who are in support of the temporary housing as well those who are in opposition of it – because whether you’re in support or opposition of the temporary housing locations, there are a lot of valid points being made from many different perspectives.

Note that I’m only touching upon a few of them – and that is because this post is intended to be more about working on action steps than it is about providing validation to the varied perspectives and the reasoning that goes along with those perspectives.

Those who are in opposition of the temporary housing are right

Crime and disruption around the locations has increased. It is clearly indicated by the stats (which still do not show a complete picture since only some people call in the incidents) that this claim is true and indisputable. To be clear, the crime stats are not showing that the temporary housing locations are the sole source, but the stats are definitely showing that there is a concentration of issues around the temporary housing locations and that overall crime is continuing to increase throughout Nanaimo.

There is increased homeless activity. The increased homeless activity is both a result of the remaining homeless issue not being sufficiently addressed as well as the immediate increase of homeless individuals that have resulted from being dispersed into the streets, alleys, bushes, and parks now that tent city has been closed. Those who weren’t housed by the temporary housing remain homeless. The amount of homeless individuals prior to the temporary housing (and tent city) being established was studied and estimated by the RCMP to exceed 400. With only 170 individuals being housed in the temporary housing locations, that means that well over 200 remain on the streets and in the alleyways and parks every day and continues to be a significant issue.

The neighbourhoods need help badly. The surrounding residents and businesses have been discussing the problems and how it is affecting them, reporting the issues, bringing the issues to leadership. Yet, it doesn’t seem to be moving the dial on anything – there’s nothing for the residents to grasp onto that helps them feel like our leadership is leading the way through this, which they can and must do. As a result anger and frustration is increasing – they are very understandably feeling like they are being left on their own to deal with this problem that they did not cause. Without a doubt, other levels of government are responsible for various aspects, however, it is our Council that needs to hold the other levels of government responsible and advocate for increased resources and supports on the city’s behalf.

Those who are in support of the temporary housing are right

Housing is an important first step. It’s a very good thing that the Province has stepped up and provided temporary housing for 170 homeless individuals – it was a necessary first step, and one that was well overdue that resulted from an overabundance of inaction. Without that temporary housing we would still have 170 additional homeless individuals on top of the over 200+ other homeless individuals that are still roaming the streets, sleeping in alleyways and parks. It’s true that incidents of crime would still be at the high level that they’re at, though possibly more dispersed throughout the city. That doesn’t make things better, and the steps towards making more housing available must continue as a high priority.

The problem existed long before the temporary housing was established. It’s important to recognize the estimated number of over 400 homeless individuals that existed prior to the temporary housing – and prior to tent city as well I might add. While there are definitely some issues arising from the temporary housing locations that contain 170 previously homeless individuals, the fact is that the temporary housing locations aren’t to blame for all of the issues we are currently facing in regards to increased crime and disruption throughout the surrounding communities – let alone the broad community of Nanaimo itself.

We need to support continued progress on this issue. Nobody claimed this was going to fix everything; it’s just a start. With that in mind, I would suggest that it’s counter productive for those in the community who choose to continue down the road of blaming the temporary housing locations and the homeless for everything. Not everyone is, but many are. This situation is aggravated even further by those who are, and continue to, spread misinformation and hate. We need to continue making forward progress, and to drastically increase the amount of mental health and addiction supports available along with more housing. It isn’t going to be easy but we need to persist, for the benefit of all residents in our community. There is no turning back, that will only make things worse.

Some common ground may exist

At the core of those who support or oppose the temporary housing, I believe most rational people recognize to some extent that in order to tackle this overall issue effectively, we need to have sufficient supports available which address mental health and addiction issues. The supports required to address mental health and addiction issues are insufficient unless you have the means to pay for them out of pocket.

Complicating this, is that due to the nature of mental health and addiction, many of the supports require immediate access. The problem is further compounded as it could be argued that some of the most important mental health and addiction supports are the ones that handle immediate crisis situations and the entry point to taking steps forward that can lead to long term success. These kinds of services fail when there is long wait lists and insufficient access to the resources needed, and that inevitably results in a huge amount of first responder resources continuing to be applied towards isolated incidents which often repeat themselves.

The bottom line is that in order to address things properly and achieve success beyond simply getting people housed, a significant amount of mental health supports and addiction treatment programs are needed to address the specialized focuses detox, sobering and assessment, stabilization, and supportive recovery services.

And to get all that, we need to work together – these type of supports and programs require involvement from multiple levels of government, our leadership needs to be proactive and take action, and we need to provide our support.

Even if you are not on board with this, I hope that you can at least recognize the negative financial implications of doing nothing or going backwards – it’s already been well proven throughout the world that addressing the issue, is by far the less costly way to proceed forth. The longer that we spin our wheels on this without moving forward with more positive steps, the more it will continue to cost the taxpayers.

Communication is key

Before we get to the four action steps, I think this is important to point out because “What is our Council actually doing about this issue anyways?” is a question I’m frequently hearing, and I would agree that nobody really knows – nobody in the general community that is. I say this not to condemn Council or suggest that they aren’t doing anything, but to actually start driving home the importance of communication which is sorely lacking on this subject.

Resentment and stigma against the homeless and temporary housing locations continues to increase as leadership remains relatively quiet while incidents continue to escalate. This silence from leadership is counter-productive and harmful, as it leads the surrounding neighbours and businesses to start believing that they are “on their own”, and also harms the efforts of both the care providers that are “in the trenches” each and every day with those who need help, as well as those who are actually making positive steps forward.

The feeling of helplessness and perception of inaction has compounded itself to the point that some have even shifted their views on this issue from previously being in support of helping the less fortunate, to now being in opposition.

Things are getting so bad this way, that with all of the growing frustration and minimal communication by leadership, the issue is increasingly reaching levels of vigilantism. Anger and frustration will only continue to escalate if leadership does not begin communicating on this issue properly.

It’s very important that Council begins to lead on this matter publicly. Even though it inevitably means that some people will not be pleased with what’s being said, it’s not about saying things that will please everyone. It’s about keeping everyone in the community more informed about what is happening and what isn’t, actions being taken, and being upfront in showing that citizen’s concerns are not being ignored or dismissed.

Moving forward, here are four action steps that I have came up with to begin addressing the current situation and beyond.

Actions for Council to consider

Action Item 1 – Commit to being more transparent and increasing communication on this matter

I’ve discussed it to an extent above, but I want to add to it here because there are specific actions that can be taken towards this. It’s critical that Council significantly increases communication to the public on this matter – the longer this lack of communication occurs, the further the community will divide and the worse off it will be.

I would suggest that a good action step for Council towards this, would be to rise and report each and every time Council meets in-camera about the subject, and after public meetings as well where this issue is discussed. Speak about this frequently, as a Council – and as individual members of Council as well. Engage the community!

Create frequent information releases – begin putting out information about what action steps have/haven’t occurred, what is happening and what isn’t, and what the next steps are. Embrace the difficult conversations rather than avoid them. Keep the public informed – it helps – if the information releases are genuine and discuss both the successes and failures – the difficulties and hurdles, and the progress being made (or lack of).

This needs to be done frequently, until the situation is completely under control – which will obviously take some time, as there is no short term solution that will fix it all.

Another part of this step is in regards to being open, transparent, and accountable. I believe that almost all of the requests to specific entities such as BC Housing and our Provincial Government that Council directs of staff, should be done publicly through Council directives – and there’s good reasons for that. One reason, is that too much is being done in-camera which quite simply doesn’t need to be, and that circumvents accountability. I’m not saying that some of the conversations don’t need to happen behind closed doors – because sometimes they do. What I am saying, is that there is a large amount of communication and directives that should be public. Council needs to take responsibility for that.

There are also political advantages in keeping directives public as it shows that the situation is top of mind and being actively worked on. It helps show where progress is being made, and at times also shows where the ball is being dropped. This results in a natural effect of applying appropriate political pressure when it’s done correctly, and also helps inform and shape public opinion. There is no benefit to our city in keeping everything behind closed doors to the extent that it has been, rather, I am suggesting that it is entirely at the city’s expense by doing that because it creates obscurity towards responsibilities and accountability. Who is actually being protected by keeping everything behind closed doors? Just something to think about.

Rather than further describe what I mean by political pressure, responsibility, accountability, and all the intricacies involved I’m going to move onto providing some concrete examples of actions in the form of directives which can start to address parts of the problem.

And as I think you will see, they are not punitive or condemning in nature which at this point would be counter productive – they are progressive and solution oriented, and accountability is naturally embedded in an appropriate way (in my opinion). Council can do this.

Action Item 2 – Further collaboration towards addressing the concentrated issues surrounding the temporary locations

The intent of this action item is to further collaboration in addressing the concentrated issues that are threatening the health, safety, and well-being of the neighbourhoods surrounding the temporary housing locations. It’s also worth noting that some of these items might already be in progress, however without sufficient communication around that how are we to know? A Council motion to begin addressing these concentrated issues could be drafted as follows:

That Council directs Staff to:

  1. Request the RCMP to increase enforcement in the neighbourhoods surrounding 250 Terminal Avenue and 2020 Labieux Road; and,
  2. Request the RCMP to undertake a Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED) review of the neighbourhoods surrounding 250 Terminal Avenue and 2020 Labieux Road, and provide recommendations for consideration; and,
  3. Request a collaborative meeting to occur between city Staff, Island Crisis Care Society, Pacifica Housing Advisory Association, BC Housing, location security providers, and Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing to identify and discuss potential improvements to the housing and services being provided for 250 Terminal Avenue and 2020 Labieux Road locations. Items for Staff to bring forward towards the discussion are to include the following:
    1. Discussion towards potentially improving the operational agreements in ways which further define the roles and responsibilities of each entity. If during discussion it is determined that the outcomes of an improved operational agreement would be of benefit but may require an adjustment to contractual arrangements and/or additional resources to achieve optimum service delivery, Staff is to advocate on behalf of the City of Nanaimo and request that adjustments to the contractual arrangements and/or additional resources be explored further.
    2. Discussion towards potentially improving the individual Good Neighbour agreements in ways that can help reduce any barriers identified by city staff, housing location staff, security, and/or the RCMP from being as effective as they could be towards assisting the residents reach better outcomes, upholding the intent of the agreements, improving the health, safety, and well being of the locations and concerns of the surrounding communities.
  4. Report back to the Council at the next public Council or Committee of the Whole meeting with a status update on the above items.

After this is done, Council can provide further direction and take action based on the results.

Action Item 3 – Empower the associated committees to assist

It has been indicated that Council has not yet reinstated the committees as they are considering changes to the committee structures themselves. While that is a significant and worthwhile effort to undertake, there is no reason why the committees cannot be reinstated while that work progresses. Quite simply put – there is more value to be had by having the committees assist – even in their current form – than for them not to be.

Specifically, in regards to the subject of this post – the Public Safety Committee and the Community Planning and Development Committee are residing in a state of limbo and have been since October 2018 when their meetings were suspended. These two committees are important towards this subject and have pending work to complete, along with new work that could be undertaken if they were reestablished.

To do this, Council needs to re-establish these committees and that starts by selecting and appointing a chair to each committee, directing Staff to re-establish the committee schedules, and for the committees to continue from where they left off. Council can initiate this through motions such as the following:

That Council appoint [selected Council member] as Chair of the Public Safety Committee and appoint [alternate Council member] as the backup Chair.

That Council appoint [selected Council member] as Chair of the Community Planning and Development Committee and appoint [alternate Council member] as the backup Chair. 

That Council direct Staff to:

  1. Re-establish the Public Safety Committee and the Community Planning and Development Committee meeting schedules; and,
  2. Provide Council, the Public Safety Committee, and the Community Planning and Development Committee with the report containing options for amending the Zoning Bylaw that Staff had planned to provide to the Public Safety Committee and the Community Planning and Development Committee in October 2018 prior to the stated committees being suspended. 

Once the committees are reestablished and functioning, Staff and Council can then provide additional directives for the committees to undertake towards this subject.

Action Item 4 –  Gather information and advocate for more health and addiction supports

Request Island Health and other entities to provide an update to Council in order to inform and recommend potential ways that would assist their organization towards helping address the mental health and addictions crisis. This is a step where Council can do it’s part towards listening to and showing commitment towards taking the steps it needs to take as a Council, as well as being able to further their commitment towards helping advocate in a coordinated manner towards increasing mental health and addiction supports through increased provision of resources from various entities and provincial and federal levels of government.

It’s also a step which can help better inform the general public as to the gaps that are present and where focuses need to be applied. Detox and treatment programs, placements for detox, sobering, assessment, stabilization and supportive recovery are some of the essential supports required to make lasting progress that benefits those affected and Nanaimo as a whole. Without a sufficient amount of programs and supports, the entire community – which includes both those who have mental health and addiction problems, and those who don’t – suffers. There are many entities involved in aspects of this, hence why I suggest that this is a good place to start.

A Council motion to get this ball rolling could be drafted as follows:

That Council directs Staff to:

  1. Request Island Health to deliver an informational update to a public Council meeting at a date in the near future regarding any outstanding or newly identified recommendations which would assist Island Health towards being able to fulfill its mandate of delivering a broader range of services within the City of Nanaimo which address mental health and substance abuse issues; and,
  2. Liaison with the other various entities which directly provide mental health and/or substance abuse supports to the community, and request each entity to deliver an informational update to a public Council meeting at a date in the near future regarding the work that they do along with any recommendations which would be of assistance to them towards being able to better fulfill their delivery of services; and,
  3. Report back to the Council at the next public Council or Committee of the Whole meeting with a list of entities who have been contacted and their status of confirmation including dates that each of the confirmed entity has identified they anticipate to be ready to do so.

After this is done, Council can provide further direction and take action based on the results.

In Conclusion

We’re facing a serious problem and a very large one at that. It’s going to take time to solve. What I have suggested above are just pieces of the puzzle, and I look forward to hearing more solutions come forward by others.

The problems aren’t going to get resolved by simply complaining more to each other, nor will they be solved by keeping everything behind closed doors. They’re going to get resolved by working together towards solutions. Being open, communicating, supporting, and advocating for the overall needs of the community is what will help solve the problems, and help lessen the divide.

I’m committed to doing that and I hope you are too. What do you think of the actions above, and what else do you think could be done?

Affordable Housing is Beautiful


Today I had an unexpected opportunity to check out the affordable homes at 1406 Bowen Road – there was a birthday party happening there and I needed to help someone get there to attend. I was excited, I’ve been wanting to check out this beautiful award-winning complex for quite some time.

As we drove into the parking lot for the very first time, we were greeted by someone near the entrance with a smile and a wave. It actually caught me a bit by surprise as I didn’t know them and they didn’t know us. That made me smile and I waved back – what a pleasant place!

We began to walk over to the home where the birthday party was being held. I noticed that there were a few others walking through the complex to get where they needed to go, and even with the rain, there was clearly an upbeat energy in the air.

We walked past some of the shared spaces and through the two rows of very well designed, beautiful housing until we reached the destination. The sense of community is without a doubt very strong here. It feels good.

I introduced myself and we had a great conversation, and my curiosity got the best of me – I had to ask more about their home. They smiled proudly and welcomed me in to come check it out. They explained how the energy efficient system works, and they showed me around their beautiful home that they’ve personalized and made theirs. It was very nice!

How hardship turned into a success story

They also shared how they got there. In their circumstance, late last year their family was in a rental in Harewood which had a serious flooding issue and they had to move – but they had no place to go. In this market, that’s a pretty serious thing for many to face because as we all know (we do all know this right?), affordability is a serious problem here in Nanaimo for many youth, seniors, and others.

This family was lucky – they were able to be placed into a hotel for two months under the emergency social services program. However, things began to get worse, as they can when you don’t have a stable home to call your own.

They became homeless and ended up living in their mini-van. Their children were taken away because they didn’t have a home, and although they had been approved for this new housing – it wasn’t ready yet so they were in a limbo state.

In fact, they were very close to having to live in tent city – and that’s not surprising – when there are little resources and help available (many people are only a few paychecks away from being homeless) difficult choices need to be made all along the way.

Thankfully they made it through, and into a home. Their family is moving forward in positive directions now – they have a place to call their own, they are all back together as a family, they have jobs and help support each other through this journey called life.

It’s a success story, but it’s not always that way

Often people just need a hand up for them to turn their story into one of success, and this was one of those times. There are many difficult circumstances that can lead to homelessness though, and I’d like to begin exploring that further in future posts. I hope you’ll join me.

Do you have a story to share?

The Province has taken bold steps, but the crisis isn’t over


I would like to thank the Province and all others involved in taking bold steps to assist some of the most vulnerable in our community. I am so pleased and impressed with the commitment to action that the Province and many others have towards addressing the homelessness crisis here in Nanaimo!

If we look back around 10 months ago when the Province had committed to funding a $7M 44-unit housing project which failed to reach fruition due to decisions made by our prior Council, it is clear that the Province is very serious towards helping address the situation here in Nanaimo. With the Province showing its strong commitment to our community through bold steps which have now effectively bypassed the past 10 months of our prior Council’s inaction on this crisis by provisioning 170 units of much needed temporary housing and stabilizing the current encampment at 1 Port Drive, the Province clearly recognizes the severity and urgency of this crisis in our community. You can read more about the 170 unit project here. In statements to the media, the Province has also stated that they will be lining up 40 to 50 units of market rental housing for the homeless.

I fully support the temporary measures that have been taken, and while public consultation should have been part of the 170 unit project before the plans were set into place, the reality is that it was a unique circumstance where the Province needed to take control of the situation due to prior Council’s inaction and there was simply no time left to consult with the public beforehand. Our current Council can prevent this from occurring in the future by being proactive towards consultation with the community prior to provisioning land.

But the crisis isn’t over, and for some, it’s just beginning

We hear that many tent city occupants will move to one of the sites where the temporary modular housing are being installed. However, there is a significant number of homeless individuals which will not be moving to one of the sites – those homeless individuals remain unaddressed and relatively unspoken of; they are the ones on the street and in our parks, the (all but) forgotten.

It should go without saying that along with winter arriving fast, having the homeless reside on the streets and in parks as our previous Council directed is not a solution, it’s only a continuation of the status quo. It’s detrimental to the community both socially and economically, and is life threatening during harsh weather for those who are in a homeless state. Yet, it appears to be a possibility that’s going to continue.

In a recent NanaimoNewsNOW article aptly titled “City anticipating spike in fire incidents at homeless camps as Discontent City closes” it gives a brief glimpse into just one aspect of what the reality is when the situation remains unaddressed; from June to the end of September there were 35 fire incidents around Nanaimo caused by homelessness at various camps, and more are expected as the cold begins to set in.

In fact there’s many other negative aspects as well that all too quickly become normalized when the status quo remains such as increased incidents of public disorder and conflict, and in the amount of discarded needles in our public parks and school playgrounds – to name just two more of the many aspects.

Perhaps there are solutions in the works which go beyond the status quo; it’s possible that we as citizens have not yet been informed regarding potential plans in the works that go beyond pushing the homeless into the streets and parks, and the November 30th date where the downtown encampment is slated to be deconstructed and closed in entirety.

Either way, in my opinion, there is simply too much at stake here to sit idly while time passes. Accordingly, I have provided a “Plan B” in case there is no immediate plan or that the potential “Plan A” that may be in the works is essentially a continuation of the status quo.

It’s important to recognize the gravity of the situation we are in as winter arrives. The homelessness crisis is not just inconvenient and problematic – it has escalated to a point where it’s threatening in terms of health, safety, and well-being of the community. So let’s call it what it is by definition – it’s a humanitarian crisis. A serious one.

We need to do more before things get worse

As you may or may not be aware, the homeless didn’t just all suddenly arrive here. In the 2018 Point in Time Count report that was surveyed on April 18th 2018, prior to Discontent City being established, it stated that the minimum number of individuals experiencing absolute homelessness in Nanaimo was 335 – with the RCMP estimating that based on their ongoing work with the homeless population, the total number of homeless individuals in Nanaimo is well over 400.

The Capital Regional District is projected to achieve a Functional Zero for Chronic Homelessness in 2020-2021.

The Capital Regional District is projected to achieve a Functional Zero for Chronic Homelessness in 2020-2021. View Report

Even if we were to only consider the indicated amount of 335 homeless individuals that were successfully surveyed, it’s easy to see how rapidly the crisis is escalating due to inaction; since 2016 our homeless count has almost doubled, whereas in other regions such as the Capital Regional District which are being proactive about homelessness – they are making significant progress on this matter.

So while we do have 170 units of temporary housing being prepared for the end of November (which I am very thankful for), it cannot stop there; there’s many homeless individuals left with nowhere else to turn that are part of our community.

The City must continue working on the temporary aspects before Winter arrives. Our Council needs to take proactive steps, and advocate for more supports from the Province to assist with short term measures. This is a humanitarian crisis, and it needs to be treated as such.

Our Council must be proactive

The homelessness crisis faced here in Nanaimo literally affects everyone in our community, whether it be directly or indirectly. The longer we avoid addressing this crisis the worse things become for everyone, as we have seen. It takes time to get solutions of this nature into place and the more reactive we are, the less effective the results are – you can tell the solutions are purely reactive when the outcomes are resulting in a significant waste of resources and the many detrimental effects to local businesses and the community as a whole remain.

Sound familiar? Of course it does, that’s how it’s been approached in the past – Nanaimo has been experiencing the outfall of this type of approach for quite some time now, and the issue has escalated significantly into a crisis in many ways as a result.

To be effective, Council must be proactive and begin addressing this crisis in a broader sense; for the community, local businesses, and those who are in a homeless state.

To be proactive, Council needs to look at both the short and long term steps realistically, and to start, that means looking at the scope of the crisis.

It’s actually important that we all do that, because it’s up to us all as citizens to recognize the significance and importance of addressing this crisis and help support our Council towards taking large strides forward on this matter.

So how big is this crisis?

Thankfully with the 2018 Point in Time Count report that the Nanaimo Homelessness Coalition completed earlier this year, we know there are at least 335 homeless individuals here, and that realistically the number is much closer to 400.

With the documented number of 335 and the number of 400+ being estimated by the RCMP in the 2018 Point in Time Count report as being the amount of individuals that are in a homeless state here in Nanaimo as of April 2018, it’s reasonable to consider a range between 335-400 as being a fair number to base short term crisis planning upon.

If we don’t, we’re not looking at this with a broad enough scope and all measures applied will continue to be reactive as the numbers continue to increase proportionally, let alone due to the other key factors which are accelerating the crisis.

When we look at the amount of temporary sheltering that is currently available (or soon to be made available according to statements made by the provincial governments), it amounts to 286-296 units of accommodation:

  • 40-50 potential rental subsidies
  • 80 temporary units on Terminal Ave.
  • 90 temporary units on Labieux Rd.
  • 23 emergency shelter beds at the New Hope Centre for men
  • 21 emergency shelter beds at the Samaritan House for women
  • 32 emergency shelter beds at the Extreme Weather Shelter

This is positive as it reduces the scope of the immediate crisis significantly from the start range of 335-400 homeless individuals.

But it doesn’t mean we’re out of the water yet. With these numbers, we can see that the scope of the immediate crisis which remains unaddressed is somewhere between 49-114 homeless individuals.

To be very clear about what this means – it means that Nanaimo has between 49-114 homeless individuals which will soon be facing life threatening conditions on our streets, and in our parks and playgrounds – if a plan isn’t in place when winter conditions arrive.

Addressing the range of 49-114 homeless before winter arrives

This is where things could start to get more difficult because it is such a short time before winter arrives, but it actually doesn’t need to be difficult if our Council is seriously committed to action and takes solid steps forward.

As citizens we can help make things easier too. We all need to accept the reality of this humanitarian crisis and support our Council to be bold and decisive with this in mind – recognizing that the solutions however they are implemented simply aren’t going to be perfect – and they most likely won’t please everyone.

The bottom line is that we cannot continue to accept the status quo, and as well, NIMBYism cannot continue to influence decision making – as I stated above – it’s detrimental to the community both socially and economically, and is life threatening during harsh weather for those who are in a homeless state.

So if the potential “Plan A” that may be in the works is essentially a continuation of the status quo or doesn’t address the immediate aspects sufficiently, what can we do?

Let’s talk about a “Plan B”

Since it’s too late now to provision more temporary modular housing before winter arrives – even if the City was to request it – it simply won’t be ready in time. I would suggest that we should start discussing alternate plans just in case there isn’t a “Plan A” already being developed which will temporarily handle this situation sufficiently.

As a “Plan B”, I would propose that Council direct Staff to engage further with the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing to request an increase in commitment towards rental supplements for the homeless; an increase from the original number of 40 to 50 that was committed to, to a number that can properly address the life threatening weather conditions that will soon be upon the remainder of the homeless individuals who do not have shelter. To address that, it would require a commitment of 89 to 154 rental supplements in total (rather than just 40 to 50).

Staff has excellent documentation from the Nanaimo Homelessness Coalition to provide the Province as part of validating the request – the request for more assistance isn’t unreasonable. We are talking about 49 to 114 homeless individuals that are at life threatening risk if sufficient shelter isn’t available.

A temporary “Plan B” solution can proceed forth in a rapid manner if Council takes action and passes a motion such as the following:

Plan B Motion

Whereas Nanaimo is facing a humanitarian crisis that is threatening the health, safety, and well-being of the community, and that there is significant potential for life threatening conditions to exist during extreme weather conditions for the remaining 49 to 114 homeless individuals which are not addressed by the interim measures currently in progress, Council hereby directs Staff to:

  1. Consult with the Nanaimo Homelessness Coalition to seek input and assistance towards fortifying a case to request further assistance towards interim shelter measures from the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. The request for further interim shelter assistance may consist of an increase in the commitment towards rental supplements to be made available from 40-50, up to 89-154 or other amount as recommended by the Nanaimo Homeless Coalition, and/or other assistance towards interim shelter measures that the Nanaimo Homelessness Coalition recommends; and,
  2. Arrange a meeting with the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing to:
    1. Discuss the potential life threatening conditions that exist for the remaining 49 to 114 homeless individuals for which there is no interim shelter available during extreme weather conditions this winter season; and,
    2. Discuss potential solutions moving forward which can further address short-term shelter requirements during this winter season; and,
    3. Request further commitment towards interim sheltering measures which can address the unavailability of shelter for the remaining homeless individuals for which the current interim plans does not accommodate; and,
  3. Report back to Council at the next Council meeting with a status update on items 1 and 2.

In Conclusion

In this post I have went into detail around our immediate homelessness crisis and proposed a solution in the form of a “Plan B” which can help address short term aspects of the crisis. In a future post I will begin to tackle some of the other aspects around homelessness, but for now it’s time to wrap this up.

What are your thoughts around all of this – do you like the proposed “Plan B” or do you have another plan to suggest which could further address the immediate crisis?

Will you be supportive of our Council taking proactive bold steps to move forward with actions that help address the homelessness crisis we face here in Nanaimo?

We lost another member of our community to the opioid crisis


Early this morning, we lost another member of our community to the opioid crisis, did anyone know her? My condolences go out to her family and friends, this must be a very difficult time.

Through life, you can bet that she faced difficulties that would probably be hard to imagine. This member of our community lost her way, and slipped through the cracks. I don’t know her story but maybe you do. What I do know, is that she had lost most everything.

When she was a baby, you can bet that people clambered around her exclaiming how special and precious she was – and it couldn’t be more true. Imagine how that must of felt for her as she grew and then spiraled, and how it would have felt to those who were close to her.

Step ahead to now – when she gave out what would be her last cry for help as an adult, we failed her as a society and as a community. Because make no mistake, the people under the throes of addiction are crying out for help – whether they say it or not, and whether you think they deserve the help or not.

They don’t have it easy, they are struggling to cope and survive. There are so many reasons why people have ended up at at this state, many things that can be hard to understand let alone relate to.

But we should at least be able to understand and agree that this young lady needed more help. At least that’s what I hope. Whether or not we can agree on that, unfortunately she didn’t get enough of the kind of help she needed before it was too late.

How many more members of our community are we going to lose before we can reach some sort of common ground on this – that we need to work together and help these people. These people are someone that can have a future, they are someone’s family member, they are someone’s friend. It could be someone in your family or a friend next, and for many – it has been. We are in a serious crisis here.

The bottom line in my opinion is this. We are seriously failing here as a community and society around this, and we need to do better as a community to try and help – propagating indifference and making excuses for not helping does exactly that – it doesn’t help, just as enabling doesn’t help either. So the fault doesn’t lay on any one person for this. The fault lays on us all collectively.

We can’t pretend the problem doesn’t exist. We can’t make excuses that continue the status quo. It’s up to us all to stand together where we can and do our best to keep all of our community safe as best as we can.

Let’s try and get past this polarized nonsense, it’s of no help. I get it – it’s frustrating. It’s frustrating for everyone we all share that feeling. Yet, this isn’t a simple problem, and there isn’t a simple answer. What is actually making excuses that cause indifference, and what is enabling a worsened condition – and those two things might be part of the root sources of the polarization.

So maybe we need to just get past that for now and go deeper. So I ask you – to start with, how can we build bridges and overcome our differences of opinions on this subject to an extent that we can at least help out together in some way?

Today we lost another member of our community. Does it matter to you that someone’s future has been stripped away, or that someone’s loved one was lost in tragedy?

Of course it does. So what are we willing to do, to start working together on this?